For almost all of hip hop’s existence, rappers and artists were judged, at least to some degree, on how “real” they were. “Real”, of course, didn’t mean honest or sincere, but was specifically defined as having “the right type of background”. Being poor, being raised in the ghetto, family strife or abandonment; these were all evidence of being “real”. Selling drugs, being in a gang, or being a criminal were even better signs that you were “real”. This stemmed from the fact that many of the first superstars of hip hop were many of these things; but, people quickly confused cause and effect. Probably aided by the fact that people were tired of the glitz and production of acts like Madonna and Prince and hair metal, and basically everything from the 80’s, it reached a point were you couldn’t be considered good unless you were “real”.
Then “real” changed. America discovered reality television, first with The Real World, then with Survivor, and then on basically every channel on the dial. Suddenly, America demanded to see “real” people acting “real”. This time, “real” meant “acting absurdly” and “being an asshole”. America loved to watch Russell stab every other Survivor in the back. We loved to watch kids get drunk and punch each other on the Real World. We love to watch those cackling “real” housewives say and do horrible things to each other.
Interestingly, when a cast member finally gets rightfully pissed, the offender often says something to the effect of “you can’t handle me because I’m real” or, “people don’t like me because I speak the truth”. No sweetie, people don’t like you because you’re an asshole.
The problem is that this notion that having no filter, of speaking “the truth” all the time, has become a desired trait. That is, people want to have no filter, to be able to say whatever they want, whenever they want. But, of course, nobody really wants to be around those people. A lot of people want to be a “real” housewife, but nearly everyone would kill themselves if they had to be around one all day.
The bottom line is people don’t want unfettered honesty. Even if that honesty might be constructive or helpful, people will reject you if you put it in the wrong wrapper. “Honey, your ass looks fat”, even if true, even if it serves as a wake up call and prompts weight loss and health gains, isn’t going to win you any points.
People want sincerity.
The strict meaning of the word is nearly identical, but where honesty is cold and blunt, sincerity connotes helpfulness. A sincere opinion comes from a desire to build, not a desire to destroy. It’s hard to ignore a sincere opinion because when you hear one, you can feel that someone is trying to help. So don’t be “real”. Don’t be “honest”. Be sincere. It might mean you have to bite your tongue once in a while, but you’ll be much better off for it.
And, if your opinion about something doesn’t come from a desire to build, to better, to enhance, it’s probably better left unsaid. After all, your “honest” opinion isn’t likely to be heeded anyway.